Skip to content
Brent$117.6Gas TTF$1,192USD453.87 ₸
MunaiHub
Reservoir engineeringDrive mechanisms and material balance Intermediate 22 min read

Material balance for gas reservoirs

The material balance of a gas accumulation is an account of the gas that is left in the pores. The gas that has not been produced fills all the space that the produced gas has left, and this is why the reservoir pressure falls. For a closed accumulation (one with no water coming in), the ratio p/Zp/Z falls along a straight line as cumulative production grows. Here p/Zp/Z is the reservoir pressure divided by the gas deviation factor (the factor that corrects the ideal-gas law for a real gas). The extension of this line to zero gives the gas initially in place.

Why it matters

From pressure measurements and production records, the method gives the gas in place without maps and without volumetric parameters (area, thickness, porosity and the like). It shows whether water is holding up the pressure. It tells us what the pressure will be after a given withdrawal, and how much gas can be recovered down to the abandonment pressure (the pressure at which production stops being worthwhile). It is the main way of monitoring the development of gas fields. It can also mislead us easily if water influx is not recognised.

Quick refresher

  • In a closed accumulation the pore volume occupied by gas is constant: the gas that remains fills the same space that all the gas filled at the start, GBgi=(G−Gp)BgGB_{gi} = (G - G_p)B_g.
  • Since BgB_g is proportional to Z/pZ/p, we get the straight line p/Z=(pi/Zi)(1−Gp/G)p/Z = (p_i/Z_i)(1 - G_p/G). On the p/Zp/Z axis it cuts off the initial value pi/Zip_i/Z_i, and on the production axis it cuts off the gas in place GG.
  • We must plot exactly p/Zp/Z. A straight line drawn through the pressure gives a gas in place that is too low by tens of per cent for a deep accumulation, and too high for a shallow one.
  • Under volumetric depletion drive (the gas is produced only by its own expansion) the gas recovery factor is 1−(pa/Za)/(pi/Zi)1 - (p_a/Z_a)/(p_i/Z_i). It depends only on the initial and the abandonment pressure. For the lesson's accumulation, with an abandonment pressure of 3 MPa, it is 86%.
  • Water influx holds up the pressure: the p/Zp/Z points lie above the straight line of a closed accumulation, and a line through the early points overestimates the gas in place. The sign is a growth of the apparent gas in place from one measurement to the next.
  • Water traps gas at high pressure, so under an active water drive the gas recovery factor is lower than under depletion drive. The condensate that was produced was gas in the reservoir, so it is added to the production as its gas equivalent.
Key relationships
G Bgi=(G−Gp) BgG\,B_{gi} = (G - G_p)\,B_g

balance of a closed gas accumulation (volumes at reservoir conditions)

pZ=piZi(1−GpG)\dfrac{p}{Z} = \dfrac{p_i}{Z_i}\left(1 - \dfrac{G_p}{G}\right)

the p/Zp/Z line; pressures are absolute, ZZ is at reservoir temperature

GpG=1−pa/Zapi/Zi\dfrac{G_p}{G} = 1 - \dfrac{p_a/Z_a}{p_i/Z_i}

gas recovery factor of a closed accumulation at the abandonment pressure pap_a

GpBg+WpBw=G (Bg−Bgi)+WeG_pB_g + W_pB_w = G\,(B_g - B_{gi}) + W_e

balance with water influx: the withdrawal equals the expansion of the gas plus the water influx

Ga=GpBg+WpBwBg−Bgi=G+WeBg−BgiG_a = \dfrac{G_pB_g + W_pB_w}{B_g - B_{gi}} = G + \dfrac{W_e}{B_g - B_{gi}}

apparent gas in place: constant for a closed accumulation, growing with water influx

Common pitfalls
  • Plotting the pressure instead of p/Zp/Z.
  • Thinking that because the p/Zp/Z points fell on a straight line, there is no water influx. Under water drive the early points also fall almost on a straight line, only a flatter one.
  • Taking the pressure of one well, or of an unfinished build-up, instead of the average pressure over the accumulation brought to one datum depth.
  • Leaving out of the production the condensate, the gas used on site (fuel) and the losses.
  • Taking ZZ at a temperature other than the reservoir temperature, or converting the production and the gas in place to different standard conditions.

After this lesson you can

  • write the material balance of a closed gas accumulation and derive from it the straight line of p/Zp/Z against cumulative production
  • find the gas in place from pressure measurements and production, and explain why the plot uses p/Zp/Z and not the pressure
  • calculate the pressure after a given withdrawal, and the gas recovery factor for a given abandonment pressure
  • write the balance of an accumulation with water influx, recognise water drive from the growth of the apparent gas in place (the amount of gas the data seem to show), and estimate the volume of water that has come in
  • estimate the gas recovery factor under water drive, taking trapped gas into account
  • convert produced condensate to its gas equivalent, and name the assumptions and limits of the method

A gas accumulation as a tank of gas

The material balance compares the accumulation at two moments, before production and now, and does not follow how the fluid flows through the reservoir (the idea of the method). The accumulation is treated as one “tank” with an average reservoir pressure pp (in the lessons on well tests it is written pˉ\bar p; average reservoir pressure). For a gas accumulation the balance is especially simple: there is one mobile fluid in the pores, and there is also only one main source of energy, the expansion of the gas itself.

Gas is incomparably more compressible than anything else in the reservoir. For the gas of the lesson Gas formation volume factor, compressibility and viscosity, at 20 MPa the compressibility is about 0.046 MPa⁻¹: a pressure fall of 1 MPa increases the volume of the gas by almost 5%. The connate water and the pores together release only about 0.1% of the pore volume occupied by gas. So, as a first approximation, the pore volume occupied by gas is taken as constant.

The assumption of a single pressure holds better for gas than for oil. The viscosity of gas is tens of times lower, and pressure disturbances spread through the accumulation fast. For the lesson's gas, the product ϕμct\phi\mu c_t is 4–5 times smaller than for the oil reservoir of the lesson Flow regimes, and at the same permeability the pressure evens out that many times faster. This convenience has a flip side: the pressure looks “right” throughout the accumulation, even when water is holding it up.

Symbols and units
Quantity
GG, gas initially in place
Metric
sm³
Oilfield
scf
Quantity
GpG_p, cumulative gas production
Metric
sm³
Oilfield
scf
Quantity
BgB_g, BgiB_{gi}, gas formation volume factor, current and initial
Metric
m³/m³
Oilfield
rb/scf or ft³/scf
Quantity
pp, pip_i, average reservoir pressure, current and initial
Metric
MPa (abs.)
Oilfield
psia
Quantity
ZZ, ZiZ_i, gas deviation factor at pp and pip_i
Metric
—
Oilfield
—
Quantity
WeW_e, water influx at reservoir conditions
Metric
m³
Oilfield
rb
Quantity
WpW_p, produced water; BwB_w, its formation volume factor
Metric
sm³; m³/m³
Oilfield
STB; rb/STB

“sm³” is a standard cubic metre, a cubic metre measured at standard conditions: in the lessons of the library these are 0.101325 MPa and 20 °C (standard conditions). scf is a standard cubic foot, rb is a barrel at reservoir conditions, and STB is a barrel at standard conditions. If BwB_w is not known, it is taken as 1.

A closed accumulation: the balance and the p/Z line

An accumulation into which no water comes is called closed, and its drive is volumetric depletion drive (a volumetric reservoir). The pore volume occupied by gas does not change in it. At the start this volume held all the gas GG; now it holds the gas that is left, G−GpG - G_p. The volume of the gas in the reservoir is its amount in standard cubic metres multiplied by the formation volume factor at reservoir pressure (the ratio of the volume of the gas in the reservoir to its volume at the surface).

Material balance of a closed gas accumulation
G Bgi=(G−Gp) BgG\,B_{gi} = (G - G_p)\,B_g
where:
  • GGgas initially in place at standard conditions (GIIP), m³
  • GpG_pcumulative gas production at standard conditions, m³
  • BgiB_{gi}gas formation volume factor at the initial reservoir pressure pip_i, m³/m³
  • BgB_ggas formation volume factor at the current average reservoir pressure pp, m³/m³

Units: both sides are volumes at reservoir conditions, in m³; in oilfield units they are reservoir barrels, with GG in scf and BgB_g in rb/scf

Holds when
  • There is no water influx, and no water is produced.
  • The pore volume occupied by gas is constant: the expansion of the connate water and the decrease of the pore volume are neglected (the correction is in the advanced section).
  • The reservoir temperature is constant, and the pressure is the same throughout the accumulation.
  • The gas in the reservoir stays single-phase, and GpG_p includes all the gas produced.

On the left is the space that the gas filled at the start. On the right is the same space filled by the remaining gas at a lower pressure. The share of gas produced is set only by the ratio of the formation volume factors: Gp/G=1−Bgi/BgG_p/G = 1 - B_{gi}/B_g.

The gas formation volume factor is proportional to ZT/pZT/p (gas formation volume factor). The reservoir temperature is constant, and constant factors cancel on both sides of the equation, so in place of BgB_g we can simply put Z/pZ/p:

The p/Z line for a closed gas accumulation
pZ=piZi(1−GpG)\frac{p}{Z} = \frac{p_i}{Z_i}\left(1 - \frac{G_p}{G}\right)
where:
  • p, pip,\ p_icurrent and initial average reservoir pressure, absolute, MPa
  • Z, ZiZ,\ Z_igas deviation factor at reservoir temperature and pressures pp and pip_i, —
  • Gp, GG_p,\ Gcumulative production and gas initially in place, m³

Units: any units of pressure and gas volume: the formula contains only ratios

Holds when
  • The same as for the balance of a closed accumulation.
  • ZZ matches the composition of the reservoir gas and does not change because the composition changes during development.

In the coordinates of p/Zp/Z against cumulative production, the measurements fall on a straight line (p/Z plot). At Gp=0G_p = 0 it gives pi/Zip_i/Z_i, and it reaches zero at Gp=GG_p = G: if all the gas could be withdrawn, the pressure would fall to zero. The slope of the line is −pi/(ZiG)-p_i/(Z_iG): the larger the gas in place, the flatter the line. In Russian-language practice this technique is called the pressure decline method.

In other unit systems (1)
Gas in place from one measurement
G=Gp1−p/Zpi/ZiG = \frac{G_p}{1 - \dfrac{p/Z}{p_i/Z_i}}

GG comes out in the same units as GpG_p.

There are no constants. A calculation from one point is sensitive to a pressure error, especially while the pressure has fallen only a little. A line through several measurements is more reliable.

Reservoir pressure measurements of a closed accumulation (assumed data)
Measurement
initial
GpG_p, billion m³
0.00
pp, MPa
20.00
ZZ
0.8687
p/Zp/Z, MPa
23.022
Measurement
1st
GpG_p, billion m³
0.32
pp, MPa
18.64
ZZ
0.8646
p/Zp/Z, MPa
21.559
Measurement
2nd
GpG_p, billion m³
0.71
pp, MPa
16.91
ZZ
0.8620
p/Zp/Z, MPa
19.617
Measurement
3rd
GpG_p, billion m³
1.05
pp, MPa
15.62
ZZ
0.8622
p/Zp/Z, MPa
18.117
Measurement
4th
GpG_p, billion m³
1.46
pp, MPa
13.95
ZZ
0.8652
p/Zp/Z, MPa
16.123

The accumulation is the one from the example of the lesson Gas formation volume factor, compressibility and viscosity: 20 MPa, 80 °C, gas with a specific gravity of 0.65 (density relative to air). The pressures were calculated from the balance equation for a gas in place of 4.89 billion m³, with an assumed measurement error of up to 0.05 MPa added. ZZ comes from the generalised correlation for this gas (Ideal and real gas: the gas deviation factor (Z)).

p/Z plot of a closed gas accumulation: the measurements, the straight line and its extension to the gas in place0123450510152025Cumulative gas production, billion m³p/Z, MPa3 MPa: 4.21 billion m³start: 23.0 MPaextension of the lineG = 4.87 billion m³

Graph of the ratio p/Z from 0 to 25 MPa against cumulative production from 0 to 5 billion cubic metres. Five measurement points lie on a falling straight line, from 23.0 MPa at zero production to 16.1 MPa at 1.46 billion cubic metres. The line is continued by a dashed line and crosses the production axis at 4.87 billion cubic metres. At the p/Z level of 3.13 MPa a point is marked, with a production of 4.21 billion cubic metres.

Calculatedp/Zp/Z plot for the measurements of the table. The straight line drawn through the five points is extended to the production axis, where the gas in place is read. The marked point matches an abandonment pressure of 3 MPa (p/Zp/Z = 3.13 MPa): the production at this point is the recoverable gas under depletion drive.
Worked exampleGas in place from the p/Z plot
Given (assumed data)
Measurements
the table above: five values of GpG_p and p/Zp/Z
Gas in place by the volumetric method
4.89 billion m³ (Gas formation volume factor, compressibility and viscosity)
Solution
  1. For each measurement we find ZZ at reservoir temperature and calculate p/Zp/Z. For example, for the last one: p=13.95p = 13.95 MPa, Z=0.8652Z = 0.8652, p/Z=16.123p/Z = 16.123 MPa.
  2. We draw the line by the least-squares method (the line that fits all the points best): p/Z=23.033−4.7252 Gpp/Z = 23.033 - 4.7252\,G_p, where GpG_p is in billion m³.
  3. The gas in place is the production at which the line reaches zero: G=23.033/4.7252=4.87G = 23.033/4.7252 = 4.87 billion m³.
  4. The intercept on the p/Zp/Z axis equals pi/Zip_i/Z_i: 23.033 MPa. It corresponds to a pressure of 20.01 MPa, so the line reproduces the measured initial pressure of 20.00 MPa.
  5. A check from the two extreme measurements: G=1.461−16.123/23.022=4.87G = \dfrac{1.46}{1 - 16.123/23.022} = 4.87 billion m³.
  6. In oilfield units: 4.87⋅34.8=1694.87\cdot34.8 = 169 billion scf (1 m³ at 20 °C and 0.101325 MPa is about 34.8 scf at 60 °F and 14.7 psia).
Answer: The gas in place from the material balance is about 4.87 billion m³; the volumetric method gave 4.89 billion m³.

What it means. The difference of 0.3% is within the error of the pressure measurements. The agreement of two independent estimates says that the accumulation is closed and that all of it is connected to the wells. By the last measurement 30% of the gas in place has been produced, and the pressure has fallen by 6.05 MPa: this is already enough for a confident estimate. After the first year, when the pressure had fallen by only 1.36 MPa, a measurement error of 0.05 MPa would change the gas in place by 4%. The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

Why p/Z and not pressure

If the gas were ideal, ZZ would equal one, and the pressure itself would be a straight line against production. For a real gas, ZZ changes with pressure, and the plot of pressure against production is curved. The trouble is that the curvature is small and cannot be seen from a few early points, while the extension of such a “line” to zero pressure gives the wrong gas in place.

Pressure of a closed gas accumulation as a fraction of the initial pressure against the fraction of the gas in place produced, for three accumulations0.00.20.40.60.81.00.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of the gas in place producedFraction of the initial valuepressure, 10 MPapressure, 40 MPap/Z: one straight line for all;pressure at 20 MPa is close by

Graph with the fraction of gas in place produced from 0 to 1 on the horizontal axis and the fraction of the initial pressure from 0 to 1 on the vertical axis. A dashed straight line runs from the point (0; 1) to the point (1; 0). Three solid curves start from the same points. The curve for an accumulation at 40 MPa sags below the line and passes through 0.43 at half production. The curve for 20 MPa almost coincides with the line, at 0.51. The curve for 10 MPa runs above the line, at 0.53.

CalculatedCalculated pressure of a closed accumulation as a fraction of the initial pressure, against the fraction of the gas in place produced, for three accumulations with the same gas. The value of p/Zp/Z as a fraction of its initial value falls for all three on one straight line (dashed), while the pressure follows its own curve: below the line in a deep accumulation, above it in a shallow one.
Gas in place from a “pressure against production” line drawn through the initial point and the point of 20% production
Initial conditions
10 MPa, 60 °C
ZiZ_i
0.855
ZZ after 20% production
0.875
Gas in place from the line, % of the true value
110
Initial conditions
20 MPa, 80 °C
ZiZ_i
0.869
ZZ after 20% production
0.862
Gas in place from the line, % of the true value
97
Initial conditions
40 MPa, 120 °C
ZiZ_i
1.073
ZZ after 20% production
0.975
Gas in place from the line, % of the true value
73

The calculation is for the lesson's gas (specific gravity 0.65). The p/Zp/Z line returns the true gas in place in all three cases: 100%.

In a deep accumulation at 40 MPa, ZZ decreases as the pressure falls. The pressure falls faster than p/Zp/Z, and a line through the pressure underestimates the gas in place by more than a quarter. In a shallow accumulation at 10 MPa, ZZ grows as the pressure falls, and the gas in place is overestimated by a tenth. For the lesson's accumulation the error is only 3%, but this is a coincidence: its initial pressure is close to the minimum of ZZ.

Pressure forecast and gas recovery factor under depletion drive

Once the line is established, it also works the other way: for any future cumulative production we read p/Zp/Z from it, and from it we find the pressure. The step back from p/Zp/Z to pp needs trial and error, because ZZ itself depends on the pressure. Two or three approximations are usually enough (see the advanced section).

Production ends not when the gas has run out, but when the reservoir pressure is no longer enough to deliver gas into the pipeline at an acceptable rate and compression cost. This pressure is called the abandonment pressure. It sets the gas recovery factor.

Gas recovery factor of a closed accumulation
GpG=1−pa/Zapi/Zi\frac{G_p}{G} = 1 - \frac{p_a/Z_a}{p_i/Z_i}
where:
  • Gp/GG_p/Ggas recovery factor: the share of the gas in place that is produced by the end of development, fraction
  • pa, Zap_a,\ Z_aabandonment pressure and the gas deviation factor at it, MPa, —
  • pi, Zip_i,\ Z_iinitial reservoir pressure and the gas deviation factor at it, MPa, —

Units: a dimensionless share; pressures are absolute

Holds when
  • Depletion drive: there is no water influx.
  • The whole accumulation is brought down to one pressure pap_a by the end of development.

The gas recovery factor depends neither on the size of the accumulation nor on the withdrawal rate, only on how low the reservoir pressure can be brought. Each lowering of the abandonment pressure, for example by installing booster compressors (machines that push the gas into the pipeline when the reservoir pressure is low), adds to the recovery factor almost linearly.

Worked examplePressure after a given withdrawal, and recoverable gas
Given (assumed data)
The line from the previous example
p/Z=23.033−4.7252 Gpp/Z = 23.033 - 4.7252\,G_p (GpG_p in billion m³); G=4.87G = 4.87 billion m³
Produced by the last measurement
1.46 billion m³
Plan
1.0 million m³/d for another 6 years
Abandonment pressure
3.0 MPa; with booster compressors 1.5 MPa
Solution
  1. Production in 6 years: 1.0⋅106⋅365.25⋅6=2.19151.0\cdot10^{6}\cdot365.25\cdot6 = 2.1915 billion m³; the cumulative production is 3.6515 billion m³.
  2. From the line: p/Z=23.033−4.7252⋅3.6515=5.779p/Z = 23.033 - 4.7252\cdot3.6515 = 5.779 MPa.
  3. The pressure by trial and error. We try Z=0.93Z = 0.93: p=5.779⋅0.93=5.37p = 5.779\cdot0.93 = 5.37 MPa. At this pressure Z=0.930Z = 0.930, so the approximation has converged. The reservoir pressure after 6 years is about 5.4 MPa.
  4. Recoverable gas at an abandonment pressure of 3.0 MPa: Za=0.9591Z_a = 0.9591, pa/Za=3.128p_a/Z_a = 3.128 MPa; Gp=(23.033−3.128)/4.7252=4.21G_p = (23.033 - 3.128)/4.7252 = 4.21 billion m³. The gas recovery factor is 1−3.128/23.033=0.8641 - 3.128/23.033 = 0.864.
  5. If compressors allow the pressure to be lowered to 1.5 MPa (pa/Za=1.532p_a/Z_a = 1.532 MPa): Gp=4.55G_p = 4.55 billion m³, and the recovery factor is 0.933. The gain is about 340 million m³.
Answer: After 6 years the reservoir pressure will fall to about 5.4 MPa. Down to a pressure of 3 MPa the accumulation will give about 4.21 billion m³, which is 86% of the gas in place.

What it means. The six years come from the withdrawal plan, not from the balance. The balance says what the pressure will be after a production of 3.6515 billion m³, whenever it takes place. Whether the wells can deliver 1.0 million m³/d at a reservoir pressure of 5.4 MPa is a separate calculation of their productivity and of the pressure losses in the wellbore and at the surface (Well inflow: the well performance diagram, Nodal analysis of the production system). The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

An accumulation with water influx

If an aquifer lies under the accumulation or around it, then when the pressure falls, water enters the accumulation (water influx). The water occupies part of the pores that the gas filled before, and the remaining gas gets a smaller volume, so the pressure falls more slowly. The water that has entered, WeW_e, and the water produced, WpW_p, appear in the balance:

Material balance of a gas accumulation with water influx
G Bgi=(G−Gp) Bg+We−WpBwG\,B_{gi} = (G - G_p)\,B_g + W_e - W_pB_w
where:
  • WeW_ecumulative water influx from the aquifer at reservoir conditions, m³
  • Wp, BwW_p,\ B_wcumulative water production at standard conditions, and its formation volume factor, m³, m³/m³
  • G, Gp, Bg, BgiG,\ G_p,\ B_g,\ B_{gi}as in the balance of a closed accumulation, m³, m³, m³/m³, m³/m³
  • p, Z, pi, Zip,\ Z,\ p_i,\ Z_iin the form with p/Zp/Z: the current and initial average reservoir pressure (absolute) and the gas deviation factors at them, as on the p/Zp/Z line, MPa, —, MPa, —

Units: m³ at reservoir conditions; in oilfield units, reservoir barrels

Holds when
  • The expansion of the connate water and the decrease of the pore volume are neglected.
  • The pressure is the same throughout the accumulation, including the part flooded by water.
  • WeW_e is the whole volume of water that has entered the initial gas-filled volume, no matter how much gas it displaced and how much it bypassed.

The initial gas-filled pore volume is now shared by the gas that is left and the water that has come in and has not been produced. The equation agrees with the general equation of the lesson General material balance equation for oil reservoirs if we keep only the gas in it: the water influx, as there, is expressed in reservoir cubic metres.

In other unit systems (2)
The withdrawal equals the expansion of the gas plus the water influx
GpBg+WpBw=G (Bg−Bgi)+WeG_pB_g + W_pB_w = G\,(B_g - B_{gi}) + W_e

The same quantities. On the left is the reservoir volume of the withdrawal; on the right are the expansion of the gas of the accumulation and the water influx.

Through p/Z
pZ=piZi⋅1−Gp/G1−(We−WpBw)/(G Bgi)\frac{p}{Z} = \frac{p_i}{Z_i}\cdot\frac{1 - G_p/G}{1 - (W_e - W_pB_w)/(G\,B_{gi})}

Pressures in any identical units; (We−WpBw)/(GBgi)(W_e - W_pB_w)/(GB_{gi}) is the share of the initial gas-filled volume that water has taken.

When We=WpBwW_e = W_pB_w the denominator equals one, and the formula turns into the line of a closed accumulation.

p/Z plots for a closed accumulation and for accumulations with moderate and strong water influx012345670510152025Cumulative gas production, billion m³p/Z, MPawater breakthroughwater breakthroughstrong water influxclosedmoderateline through thefirst readings

Graph of p/Z from 0 to 25 MPa against cumulative production from 0 to 7 billion cubic metres. The straight line of the closed accumulation runs from 23 MPa down to zero at 4.89 billion cubic metres. The curve of moderate water influx runs above it, is slightly bowed, and stops at a production of 3.65 billion cubic metres at a level of 11.9 MPa. The curve of strong influx quickly levels off at 20.4 MPa and stops at 2.76 billion cubic metres. A dashed straight line through the first points of the moderate curve reaches zero at 6.2 billion cubic metres.

CalculatedCalculated p/Zp/Z plots for the lesson's accumulation at the same withdrawal rate: a closed accumulation (a straight line), moderate water influx and strong water influx. The curves with water influx stop where the water has swept 85% of the volume of the accumulation and the wells start to produce water. The dashed straight line is drawn through the first four measurements of the accumulation with moderate water influx, and it “shows” a gas in place of 6.2 billion m³ instead of 4.9.

The danger is that with water influx the early points also fall almost on a straight line, only a flatter one. The aquifer responds with a delay, and produced water appears late: the wells open the upper part of the accumulation, and the water moves towards them as a slow, even front. The reason is the mobility ratio of water to gas, M′=(krw′/μw)/(krg′/μg)M' = (k_{rw}'/\mu_w)/(k_{rg}'/\mu_g) (how easily water moves compared with gas). It is only hundredths, because the viscosity of water is tens of times higher than that of gas, and its end-point relative permeability (the value at the end of the displacement) is lower (Relative permeability). The first sign of water is not that the wells start to produce water, but a pressure that is “too good”.

The apparent gas in place helps to recognise water influx. It is the gas in place calculated from each measurement on the assumption that the accumulation is closed. For a closed accumulation it is the same from one measurement to the next. With water influx it grows.

Apparent gas in place
Ga=GpBg+WpBwBg−Bgi=G+WeBg−BgiG_a = \frac{G_pB_g + W_pB_w}{B_g - B_{gi}} = G + \frac{W_e}{B_g - B_{gi}}
where:
  • GaG_aapparent gas in place: the gas in place calculated from one measurement without taking water influx into account, m³
  • Bg−BgiB_g - B_{gi}expansion of one standard cubic metre of the gas of the accumulation when the pressure falls from pip_i to pp, m³/m³
  • Gp, Wp, Bw, We, GG_p,\ W_p,\ B_w,\ W_e,\ Gas in the balance with water influx, m³, m³, m³/m³, m³, m³

Units: m³ at standard conditions

Holds when
  • The compressibility of the pores and the connate water is neglected.
  • The pressure measurements are accurate enough. When the pressure has fallen only a little, the difference Bg−BgiB_g - B_{gi} is small, and the error is large.

The first fraction is what we can calculate from the data. The second equality shows what it means. If there is no water, Ga=GG_a = G at any date. If water comes in, a term is added to the gas in place that grows with time. When no water is produced, the first fraction is the same as the gas in place from one measurement on the p/Zp/Z plot. In the literature the difference Bg−BgiB_g - B_{gi} is written EgE_g. Here it is written out in full, because in the lesson General material balance equation for oil reservoirs this symbol stands for the expansion of the gas cap per cubic metre of oil in place.

History of an accumulation with an aquifer (assumed data)
Date
start
GpG_p, billion m³
0.000
pp, MPa
20.00
p/Zp/Z, MPa
23.02
GaG_a, billion m³
—
Date
year 1
GpG_p, billion m³
0.365
pp, MPa
18.55
p/Zp/Z, MPa
21.46
GaG_a, billion m³
5.4
Date
year 2
GpG_p, billion m³
0.731
pp, MPa
17.37
p/Zp/Z, MPa
20.14
GaG_a, billion m³
5.8
Date
year 3
GpG_p, billion m³
1.096
pp, MPa
16.36
p/Zp/Z, MPa
18.98
GaG_a, billion m³
6.2
Date
year 4
GpG_p, billion m³
1.461
pp, MPa
15.45
p/Zp/Z, MPa
17.92
GaG_a, billion m³
6.6
Date
year 5
GpG_p, billion m³
1.826
pp, MPa
14.62
p/Zp/Z, MPa
16.93
GaG_a, billion m³
6.9

The same accumulation, connected with an aquifer; the withdrawal is 1.0 million m³/d, and no water is produced. The rate of water influx is taken, as in the examples of the lessons Reservoir drive mechanisms and General material balance equation for oil reservoirs, as proportional to the pressure fall; the coefficient here is 700 m³/(d·MPa) at reservoir conditions. The apparent gas in place GaG_a is calculated in the example below.

Apparent gas in place against cumulative production for a closed accumulation and for accumulations with water influx0.00.51.01.52.04681012Cumulative gas production, billion m³Apparent gas in place, billion m³closed accumulation: 4.89 billion m³moderate water influxstrong water influx

Graph of the apparent gas in place from 4 to 12 billion cubic metres against cumulative production from 0 to 2 billion cubic metres. A horizontal line at 4.89 is the closed accumulation. The curve of moderate water influx rises from 5.4 at a production of 0.37 to 6.9 at 1.83 billion cubic metres, with five points on it. The curve of strong influx goes steeply up and exceeds 12 at a production of about 1.2 billion cubic metres.

CalculatedApparent gas in place for three calculated histories of the lesson's accumulation. For the closed accumulation it is constant and equal to the true gas in place. With water influx it grows from the very first measurement, the faster the stronger the aquifer. The points are the values from the table.
Worked exampleWater influx from the pressure history
Given (assumed data)
History
the table above; the calculation is shown for the fifth year
Gas in place by the volumetric method GG
4.89 billion m³; gas-filled pore volume 25.92 million m³
Initial conditions
pi=20p_i = 20 MPa; Bgi=0.005302B_{gi} = 0.005302 m³/m³
Water production
none
Solution
  1. The formation volume factor in the fifth year: p=14.62p = 14.62 MPa, Z=0.8636Z = 0.8636, Bg=Bgi⋅pi/Zip/Z=0.005302⋅23.0216.93=0.007209B_g = B_{gi}\cdot\dfrac{p_i/Z_i}{p/Z} = 0.005302\cdot\dfrac{23.02}{16.93} = 0.007209 m³/m³.
  2. The withdrawal at reservoir conditions: GpBg=1.826⋅109⋅0.007209=13.16G_pB_g = 1.826\cdot10^{9}\cdot0.007209 = 13.16 million m³.
  3. The expansion of a cubic metre of gas: Bg−Bgi=0.001907B_g - B_{gi} = 0.001907 m³/m³.
  4. The apparent gas in place: Ga=13.16⋅106/0.001907=6.90G_a = 13.16\cdot10^{6}/0.001907 = 6.90 billion m³. Year by year it grows: 5.4, 6.2 and 6.9 billion m³ in the first, third and fifth year. The accumulation is not closed.
  5. With a gas in place of 4.89 billion m³, the expansion of the gas gave 4.89⋅109⋅0.001907=9.334.89\cdot10^{9}\cdot0.001907 = 9.33 million m³. The rest is water: We=13.16−9.33=3.8W_e = 13.16 - 9.33 = 3.8 million m³, which is 15% of the gas-filled pore volume.
  6. A closed accumulation after the same withdrawal would have a pressure of 12.55 MPa, which is 2.1 MPa lower than the measured one.
Answer: In five years about 3.8 million m³ of water has come into the accumulation. The apparent gas in place has grown from 5.4 to 6.9 billion m³, against a true 4.89.

What it means. A line drawn through all six p/Zp/Z points of this table would give 6.9 billion m³, which is 41% more than the true gas in place, although the points depart from it by no more than 0.3 MPa. The bend (the end points above the line, the middle ones below it) can be seen only when the pressure measurements are accurate. The conclusion about water influx rests on an independent estimate of the gas in place. When there is none, the gas in place and the water influx must be found together by fitting an aquifer model (Aquifer models: water influx, Straight-line material balance (Havlena–Odeh method)). The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

Gas recovery factor under water drive

For oil, an active aquifer is a blessing: it maintains the pressure and displaces the oil. For gas it is different. As water moves through the pores, it leaves trapped gas behind it: the residual gas saturation SgrS_{gr}, roughly 20 to 40% of the pore volume. This gas is trapped at the pressure that the accumulation had when the water arrived, and with a strong influx that pressure is high: each cubic metre of pore space keeps many standard cubic metres of gas.

The second loss is the gas in those parts of the accumulation that the water has not reached by the time the wells start to produce water. The share of the accumulation's volume that the water has swept is called the volumetric sweep efficiency EVE_V. This is the whole volumetric sweep. In the lessons on waterflooding the same letter stands for the vertical sweep (over the thickness), and the volumetric sweep is written as the product EAEVE_AE_V (recovery factor in waterflooding). In the swept part, trapped gas is left. In the unswept part, there is gas at its initial saturation. All of it is at the abandonment pressure pap_a.

Gas recovery factor under water drive
GpG=1−pa/Zapi/Zi[EV Sgr1−Sw+(1−EV)]\frac{G_p}{G} = 1 - \frac{p_a/Z_a}{p_i/Z_i}\left[E_V\,\frac{S_{gr}}{1 - S_w} + (1 - E_V)\right]
where:
  • EVE_Vsweep efficiency: the share of the accumulation volume swept by water by the end of development, fraction
  • SgrS_{gr}residual gas saturation behind the water front, fraction
  • SwS_wconnate water saturation, fraction
  • pa, Zap_a,\ Z_areservoir pressure at the end of development and the gas deviation factor at it, MPa, —
  • pi, Zi, Gp, Gp_i,\ Z_i,\ G_p,\ Ginitial pressure and gas deviation factor, cumulative production and gas in place, MPa, —, m³, m³
  • We, Wp, Bw, BgiW_e,\ W_p,\ B_w,\ B_{gi}in the second form: the water influx, the water production and its formation volume factor, and the initial gas formation volume factor, as in the balance with water influx, m³, m³, m³/m³, m³/m³

Units: a dimensionless share

Holds when
  • At the end of development, all the remaining gas is at one pressure pap_a.
  • In the swept part the gas saturation equals SgrS_{gr}, and in the unswept part it equals the initial value, 1−Sw1 - S_w.
  • The compressibility of the pores and the connate water is neglected.

The square bracket is the share of the initial gas-filled volume in which gas has been left. At EV=0E_V = 0 it equals one, and the formula turns into the gas recovery factor of a closed accumulation. This is the same balance with water influx, only the volume of water that has come in is expressed through the sweep (the second form). The two levers of the recovery factor, the abandonment pressure and the sweep, pull in opposite directions: a strong aquifer sweeps the accumulation well, but keeps the pressure high.

In other unit systems (2)
The volume of water left in the accumulation, through the sweep
We−WpBw=EV G Bgi 1−Sgr−Sw1−SwW_e - W_pB_w = E_V\,G\,B_{gi}\,\frac{1 - S_{gr} - S_w}{1 - S_w}

WeW_e in m³ at reservoir conditions; GBgiGB_{gi} is the initial gas-filled pore volume, in m³.

There are no constants: in the swept part, the water takes the share of the pores that the displaced gas has freed.

Trapped gas as a share of the gas in place
GtrapG=EV Sgr1−Sw⋅pa/Zapi/Zi\frac{G_{trap}}{G} = E_V\,\frac{S_{gr}}{1 - S_w}\cdot\frac{p_a/Z_a}{p_i/Z_i}

GtrapG_{trap} is the gas left behind the water front, in standard m³; the rest are dimensionless shares and pressures in identical units.

There are no constants: the pore volume with trapped gas, EV GBgi Sgr/(1−Sw)E_V\,GB_{gi}\,S_{gr}/(1 - S_w), is divided by the formation volume factor at the pressure pap_a.

Worked exampleHow much gas is left behind the water front
Given (assumed data)
The lesson's accumulation
pi/Zi=23.02p_i/Z_i = 23.02 MPa; Sw=0.25S_w = 0.25
Residual gas saturation; sweep by the time the wells start to produce water
Sgr=0.30S_{gr} = 0.30; EV=0.85E_V = 0.85
Pressure at that moment (the calculated curves of the figure above)
moderate water influx: 10.5 MPa; strong: 17.6 MPa
Solution
  1. The share of the volume where gas has been left: 0.85⋅0.30/0.75+0.15=0.490.85\cdot0.30/0.75 + 0.15 = 0.49.
  2. Moderate influx: pa/Za=11.91p_a/Z_a = 11.91 MPa; the gas recovery factor is 1−(11.91/23.02)⋅0.49=0.7461 - (11.91/23.02)\cdot0.49 = 0.746.
  3. Strong influx: pa/Za=20.40p_a/Z_a = 20.40 MPa; the gas recovery factor is 1−(20.40/23.02)⋅0.49=0.5661 - (20.40/23.02)\cdot0.49 = 0.566.
  4. Trapped gas with strong influx: 0.85⋅0.40⋅20.40/23.02=0.300.85\cdot0.40\cdot20.40/23.02 = 0.30 of the gas in place; with moderate influx, 0.18.
  5. The volume of water that has come in is the same in both cases: 0.85⋅25.92⋅(1−0.30−0.25)/0.75=13.20.85\cdot25.92\cdot(1 - 0.30 - 0.25)/0.75 = 13.2 million m³.
Answer: The gas recovery factor is about 75% with moderate water influx and 57% with strong; a closed accumulation with an abandonment pressure of 3 MPa would give 86%.

What it means. The same amount of water has come in, but the losses differ. With strong influx the gas is trapped at 17.6 MPa, and 30% of the gas in place is left behind the front, against 18% with moderate influx. Hence the rule for developing gas accumulations with active water: take the gas faster than the water can arrive, so that trapping happens at the lowest possible pressure. The possibilities for this are limited by the number of wells and by the demand for gas. The calculation agrees with the balance: the production on the calculated curves by this moment is 3.65 and 2.76 billion m³. The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

Wet gas and condensate: the gas equivalent

Wet gas (gas with a lot of heavy hydrocarbons in it) is single-phase in the reservoir, but condensate (light liquid hydrocarbons) drops out of it in the separator (Types of reservoir fluids). For the balance this is the same reservoir gas, only produced as a liquid, and it must be put back into the production as gas. Fresh water that was water vapour in the reservoir is treated in the same way. The conversion goes through the number of moles: a cubic metre of liquid contains ρ/M\rho/M kilomoles, and each kilomole of gas takes the same volume at standard conditions.

Gas equivalent of condensate
GE=R Tscpsc⋅ρcMc=24.05 ρcMcGE = \frac{R\,T_{\text{sc}}}{p_{\text{sc}}}\cdot\frac{\rho_c}{M_c} = 24.05\,\frac{\rho_c}{M_c}
where:
  • GEGEgas equivalent: the volume of gas at standard conditions that 1 m³ of liquid gives, m³/m³
  • ρc\rho_cdensity of the stabilised condensate (the liquid left after the light gases are removed) at standard conditions, kg/m³
  • McM_cmolar mass of the condensate, kg/kmol
  • RRuniversal gas constant, 8.3145 kPa·m³/(kmol·K), kPa·m³/(kmol·K)
  • Tsc, pscT_{\text{sc}},\ p_{\text{sc}}standard temperature and pressure: 293.15 K and 101.325 kPa, K, kPa

Units: ρc\rho_c in kg/m³, McM_c in kg/kmol; the result is m³ of gas per m³ of liquid at 20 °C and 0.101325 MPa

Holds when
  • The vapour of the condensate at standard conditions is taken as an ideal gas (Z=1Z = 1).
  • The density and molar mass refer to the liquid whose volume is counted in the production.

24.05 m³/kmol is the volume of a kilomole of ideal gas at standard conditions. The lighter the condensate, the smaller its molar mass and the more gas it “contains”. For water (ρ\rho = 1000 kg/m³, MM = 18 kg/kmol) the equivalent is about 1340 m³ of vapour per cubic metre.

In other unit systems (1)
Oilfield units
GE=133,000 γcMcGE = 133{,}000\,\frac{\gamma_c}{M_c}

GEGE in scf of gas per barrel of condensate (STB) at 60 °F and 14.7 psia; γc\gamma_c is the specific gravity of the condensate (relative to water); McM_c in lb/lb-mol.

133,000=10.73⋅520/14.7⋅62.4⋅5.615133{,}000 = 10.73\cdot520/14.7\cdot62.4\cdot5.615: the volume of a pound-mole of gas (10.73 is the gas constant in psia·ft³/(lb-mol·°R), with 520 °R and 14.7 psia) multiplied by the mass of a barrel of water (62.4 lb/ft³ and 5.615 ft³ in a barrel).

Worked exampleProduction of wet gas with condensate taken into account
Given (assumed data)
Separator gas produced
1.40 billion m³
Stabilised condensate produced
180 thousand m³
Condensate
density 750 kg/m³; molar mass 120 kg/kmol
Solution
  1. Gas equivalent: GE=24.05⋅750/120=150.3GE = 24.05\cdot750/120 = 150.3 m³/m³.
  2. The condensate converted to gas: 180⋅103⋅150.3=27.1180\cdot10^{3}\cdot150.3 = 27.1 million m³.
  3. Production of reservoir gas: Gp=1.40+0.027=1.427G_p = 1.40 + 0.027 = 1.427 billion m³, which is 1.9% more than the separator gas.
  4. The same in oilfield units: γc=0.75\gamma_c = 0.75; GE=133,000⋅0.75/120=831GE = 133{,}000\cdot0.75/120 = 831 scf/STB.
Answer: The balance uses Gp=1.427G_p = 1.427 billion m³; the gas equivalent of the condensate is about 150.3 m³/m³.

What it means. If we leave the condensate out, all the points on the p/Zp/Z plot shift to the left by 1.9%, and the gas in place comes out too low by the same amount. For rich gas-condensate systems the correction reaches 10% and more. The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

Data, assumptions and typical mistakes

Working procedure with the p/Z plot
  1. 1
    Collect the measurements

    The average reservoir pressure on several dates, and the cumulative production on the same dates: gas, condensate and water.

  2. 2
    Convert the production to reservoir gas

    Add to the separator gas the gas equivalent of the condensate, the gas used on site and the losses.

  3. 3
    Find Z for each pressure

    From the composition or the specific gravity of the gas, at reservoir temperature and absolute pressure.

  4. 4
    Plot p/Z against cumulative production

    Draw a straight line through all the reliable points; read pi/Zip_i/Z_i and the gas in place.

  5. 5
    Check whether the accumulation is closed

    Calculate the apparent gas in place from each measurement, and compare the gas in place with the volumetric estimate. A growth of the apparent gas in place, or a gas in place clearly larger than the volumetric one, is a sign of water influx.

  6. 6
    Make the forecast

    The pressure after the planned withdrawal and the recoverable gas at the abandonment pressure. With water influx, we use an aquifer model and take trapped gas into account.

  • Average reservoir pressure. It is found from the pressure build-up in shut-in wells, brought to one datum depth and averaged over the volume (Pressure build-up analysis, Build-up in a bounded reservoir and average reservoir pressure). In a high-permeability accumulation the pressures in the wells are close. In a low-permeability or block-divided one they differ, and the model of one “tank” works poorly.
  • Complete production accounting. GpG_p includes all the gas that has left the reservoir: separator gas, gas used on site and gas burned off at a flare, and condensate and water as gas equivalents. Gas injected back is subtracted.
  • Gas properties. ZZ is for the composition of the reservoir gas and the reservoir temperature; the gas in place and the production are brought to the same standard conditions.
  • Early measurements. While the pressure has fallen by only a few per cent, the error of its measurement is comparable to the fall itself, and water influx has not yet shown itself. Early estimates of the gas in place cannot be trusted.
  • Only the connected volume. The balance “sees” the part of the accumulation whose pressure responds to the withdrawal. If the gas in place from the balance is clearly smaller than the volumetric one, part of the accumulation is not being drained.
  • No time. The balance links the withdrawal with the pressure, but does not say when that withdrawal will take place. The rates are set by the productivity of the wells and by the gas gathering system.
  • High initial pressure. In accumulations with abnormally high reservoir pressure (overpressure) the decrease of the pore volume noticeably supports the pressure, and a simple straight line overestimates the gas in place (see the advanced section; Abnormal formation pressures: origin, prediction and recognition).

Terms and symbols

Volumetric depletion drive
The drive of a closed gas accumulation: gas is produced only by its own expansion, and the pore volume occupied by gas is constant.
The p/Zp/Z plot
The dependence of the ratio of the reservoir pressure to the gas deviation factor on cumulative gas production. For a closed accumulation it is a straight line that cuts off the gas in place on the production axis.
Apparent gas in place GaG_a
The gas in place calculated from one measurement on the assumption of a closed accumulation. Its growth from one measurement to the next points to water influx.
Abandonment pressure pap_a
The pressure at which further production becomes impossible or unprofitable. It sets the gas recovery factor.
Gas recovery factor
The share of the gas initially in place that is produced by the end of development.
Residual gas saturation SgrS_{gr}
The share of the pore volume in which gas stays trapped behind the water front.
Gas equivalent
The volume of gas at standard conditions that matches a unit volume of produced condensate or water.

Common mistakes and misconceptions

Wrong

“The p/Z points fell on a straight line, so the accumulation is closed and the gas in place is determined.”

In fact

With water influx the early points also fall almost on a straight line, only a flatter one. In the lesson's example, such a line overestimates the gas in place by 41%. Whether the accumulation is closed is checked by the constancy of the apparent gas in place and by an independent volumetric estimate.

Wrong

“We can plot the pressure: Z is close to one.”

In fact

ZZ changes with pressure, and a line through the pressure is wrong: in the lesson's examples, from minus 27% for a deep accumulation to plus 10% for a shallow one. We plot p/Zp/Z.

Wrong

“Edge water raises the gas recovery factor, as it raises the oil recovery.”

In fact

Water traps gas at high pressure, and it reaches the wells before the pressure has time to fall. In the lesson's example, the gas recovery factor with strong water influx is 57%, against 86% under depletion drive.

Wrong

“Condensate is not gas, so there is no need to include it in the gas production.”

In fact

In the reservoir the condensate was part of the gas. Its production is converted to the gas equivalent and added to GpG_p; otherwise the gas in place will come out too low.

Wrong

“The p/Z plot shows how many years the field will last.”

In fact

There is no time in the balance. It shows what the pressure will be after a given withdrawal. The duration depends on the withdrawal rate, which is set by the productivity of the wells and by demand.

In depth: advanced detail

Compressibility of the pores and the connate water

The full balance of a gas accumulation contains the same term as that of an oil accumulation. When the pressure falls by Δp=pi−p\Delta p = p_i - p, the connate water expands and the pore volume decreases, and together they take from the gas the share (cwSw+cf)Δp/(1−Sw)(c_wS_w + c_f)\Delta p/(1 - S_w) of the initial gas-filled volume (expansion of water and pores).

Balance of a gas accumulation with the water and the pores taken into account
GpBg+WpBw=G (Bg−Bgi)+G Bgi cwSw+cf1−Sw Δp+WeG_pB_g + W_pB_w = G\,(B_g - B_{gi}) + G\,B_{gi}\,\frac{c_wS_w + c_f}{1 - S_w}\,\Delta p + W_e
where:
  • cw, cfc_w,\ c_fcompressibility of water and of the pore volume, 1/MPa
  • SwS_wconnate water saturation, fraction
  • Δp\Delta pfall of the average reservoir pressure from the initial one, pi−pp_i - p, MPa
  • G, Gp, Bg, BgiG,\ G_p,\ B_g,\ B_{gi}gas in place, cumulative production and gas formation volume factors, as in the balance of a closed accumulation, m³, m³, m³/m³, m³/m³
  • We, Wp, BwW_e,\ W_p,\ B_wwater influx, water production and its formation volume factor, as in the balance with water influx, m³, m³, m³/m³
  • p, Z, pi, Zip,\ Z,\ p_i,\ Z_iin the second form: the current and initial average reservoir pressure (absolute) and the gas deviation factors at them, MPa, —, MPa, —

Units: m³ at reservoir conditions; pressure and compressibilities in consistent units

Holds when

The term with water and pores behaves as one more, small, source of energy. For a closed accumulation, it is no longer p/Zp/Z that falls on the straight line, but p/Zp/Z with a correction factor (the second form). Without the correction the pressure seems “too high”, and the gas in place is overestimated, just as with water influx.

In other unit systems (1)
Closed accumulation, through p/Z
pZ[1−cwSw+cf1−Sw Δp]=piZi(1−GpG)\frac{p}{Z}\left[1 - \frac{c_wS_w + c_f}{1 - S_w}\,\Delta p\right] = \frac{p_i}{Z_i}\left(1 - \frac{G_p}{G}\right)

Pressures in MPa, compressibilities in 1/MPa (or psi and 1/psi).

There are no constants. The factor in square brackets is the share of the initial gas-filled volume that is left to the gas after the expansion of the connate water and the decrease of the pore volume.

Worked exampleHow large the correction is
Given (assumed data)
The lesson's accumulation
Sw=0.25S_w = 0.25; cw=0.45⋅10−3c_w = 0.45\cdot10^{-3} and cf=0.8⋅10−3c_f = 0.8\cdot10^{-3} MPa⁻¹
Withdrawal
1.6 billion m³ out of 4.89 billion m³
Solution
  1. The coefficient: (0.45⋅0.25+0.8)⋅10−3/0.75=1.2167⋅10−3(0.45\cdot0.25 + 0.8)\cdot10^{-3}/0.75 = 1.2167\cdot10^{-3} MPa⁻¹.
  2. Without water and pores, the pressure after such a withdrawal would be 13.43 MPa. With them it is 13.53 MPa, which is 0.10 MPa higher.
  3. The correction factor: 1−1.2167⋅10−3⋅(20−13.53)=0.99211 - 1.2167\cdot10^{-3}\cdot(20 - 13.53) = 0.9921.
  4. The gas in place from this point without the correction: 1.61−15.610/23.022=4.97\dfrac{1.6}{1 - 15.610/23.022} = 4.97 billion m³, which is 1.7% more than the true value. With the correction: 1.61−15.487/23.022=4.89\dfrac{1.6}{1 - 15.487/23.022} = 4.89 billion m³.
Answer: For the lesson's accumulation, the water and pores change the estimate of the gas in place by 1.7%.

What it means. With ordinary pore compressibility and moderate pressures, the correction is small compared with the error of the measurements, and it is neglected. In accumulations with abnormally high pressure and weakly cemented rocks, the pore compressibility is several times larger, and the pressure fall is measured in tens of megapascals. There the early p/Zp/Z points run noticeably flatter than the late ones, and a line through them gives a gas in place that is too high by tens of per cent. The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

How to go from p/Z to pressure

The plot gives p/Zp/Z, but well calculations need the pressure. The equation p=(p/Z)⋅Z(p)p = (p/Z)\cdot Z(p) is solved by successive approximations: we assume a value of ZZ, find pp, use it to refine ZZ, and repeat. Because ZZ changes slowly with pressure, the approximations converge in two or three steps. Another way is to calculate in advance a table of p/Zp/Z for a range of pressures at reservoir temperature, and find the pressure by interpolation.

Worked examplePressure from a value of p/Z
Given (assumed data)
Value from the plot
p/Z=10.0p/Z = 10.0 MPa
Gas and temperature
the lesson's gas, 80 °C
Solution
  1. First approximation, Z=1Z = 1: p=10.0p = 10.0 MPa. At this pressure Z=0.8855Z = 0.8855.
  2. Second: p=10.0⋅0.8855=8.855p = 10.0\cdot0.8855 = 8.855 MPa; Z=0.8946Z = 0.8946.
  3. Third: p=10.0⋅0.8946=8.946p = 10.0\cdot0.8946 = 8.946 MPa; Z=0.8938Z = 0.8938, a change in the fourth digit.
Answer: p≈8.94p \approx 8.94 MPa at Z≈0.8938Z \approx 0.8938.

What it means. The same technique was used in the example with the pressure forecast. If we start not from one but from the ZZ of the nearest measurement, one step is enough. The data in this example are assumed for illustration.

Connections to other topics

Check yourself

  1. 1

    On the p/Z plot of a closed gas accumulation, the straight line cuts off a segment of 12 billion m³ on the cumulative production axis. What is this quantity?

    1. A.The production at the moment of the last measurement
    2. B.The gas initially in place that is connected with the wells
    3. C.The recoverable gas
    4. D.The pore volume of the accumulation
    Show the answer

    Correct answer: B. The gas initially in place that is connected with the wells

    The line reaches p/Z=0p/Z = 0 at Gp=GG_p = G: if the gas could be withdrawn completely, the pressure would fall to zero. This is the gas initially in place of that part of the accumulation whose pressure responds to the withdrawal. The recoverable gas is smaller: it is read at the level of the abandonment pressure.

  2. 2

    A closed gas accumulation has pi/Zi=30p_i/Z_i = 30 MPa. After a withdrawal of 2.0 billion m³, p/Z=24p/Z = 24 MPa is measured. Find the gas in place and the gas recovery factor for an abandonment value of pa/Za=4p_a/Z_a = 4 MPa.

    Show the answer

    Gas in place: G=2.01−24/30=10G = \dfrac{2.0}{1 - 24/30} = 10 billion m³. Gas recovery factor: 1−4/30=0.8671 - 4/30 = 0.867, that is 8.67 billion m³ of recoverable gas.

  3. 3

    Why do we plot p/Z and not the reservoir pressure?

    1. A.ZZ accounts for water influx
    2. B.It is easier to choose the scale
    3. C.The amount of gas in a constant pore volume is proportional to p/Zp/Z, not to pp: ZZ changes with pressure
    4. D.The pressure cannot be measured accurately
    Show the answer

    Correct answer: C. The amount of gas in a constant pore volume is proportional to p/Zp/Z, not to pp: ZZ changes with pressure

    From the equation of state of a real gas, the number of moles in a given volume at constant temperature is proportional to p/Zp/Z. So it is exactly p/Zp/Z that falls linearly with production. The pressure by itself follows a curve, and its extension from the early points gives the wrong gas in place.

  4. 4

    The apparent gas in place calculated from three successive measurements is 12, 15 and 19 billion m³. What does this mean?

    1. A.The gas behaves as an ideal gas
    2. B.The estimate is being refined; we should trust the last value
    3. C.The production is being overstated in the accounting
    4. D.Water is coming into the accumulation, and the pressure falls more slowly than in a closed one
    Show the answer

    Correct answer: D. Water is coming into the accumulation, and the pressure falls more slowly than in a closed one

    Ga=G+We/(Bg−Bgi)G_a = G + W_e/(B_g - B_{gi}): for a closed accumulation the second term is zero, and the apparent gas in place is constant. A steady growth is a sign of water influx (or of another source of energy that has not been counted, such as compaction of the rock). The true gas in place is smaller than any of the three values.

  5. 5

    The gas in place by the volumetric method is 8.0 billion m³, and Bgi=0.0045B_{gi} = 0.0045 m³/m³. At the date of the measurement 2.0 billion m³ of gas has been produced, no water has been produced, and Bg=0.0056B_g = 0.0056 m³/m³. How much water has come into the accumulation?

    Show the answer

    Withdrawal: GpBg=2.0⋅109⋅0.0056=11.2G_pB_g = 2.0\cdot10^{9}\cdot0.0056 = 11.2 million m³. Expansion of the gas: G(Bg−Bgi)=8.0⋅109⋅0.0011=8.8G(B_g - B_{gi}) = 8.0\cdot10^{9}\cdot0.0011 = 8.8 million m³. Water influx: We=11.2−8.8=2.4W_e = 11.2 - 8.8 = 2.4 million m³ at reservoir conditions.

  6. 6

    50 thousand m³ of condensate has been produced, with a density of 780 kg/m³ and a molar mass of 130 kg/kmol. What volume of gas must be added to the production in the material balance?

    Show the answer

    GE=24.05⋅780/130=144.3GE = 24.05\cdot780/130 = 144.3 m³/m³. The addition is 50⋅103⋅144.3≈7.250\cdot10^{3}\cdot144.3 \approx 7.2 million m³ of gas at standard conditions.

Updated: 19 October 2026